The Scottish midfielder, Scott McTominay, had been a familiar face at Old Trafford, having risen through Manchester United’s youth ranks to become a first-team regular.
However, in a surprising twist, McTominay was allowed to depart during the summer transfer window, much to the disbelief of fans and pundits alike. Despite his pivotal role in rescuing Erik ten Hag’s side with key goals and performances in the previous season, Manchester United decided to open the exit door for McTominay, sparking debate about the club’s transfer strategy.
Manchester United eventually agreed to a deal with Napoli, selling McTominay for around thirty million euros. His move to Italy has since been seen as a major coup for Napoli, who were already looking strong under the leadership of Antonio Conte. The Scottish international quickly settled into life in Serie A, contributing with a goal and an assist in his early appearances for the Italian side. His performances have further fueled criticism of Manchester United’s decision to let him go.
Paolo Di Canio, the outspoken former striker, has been one of the most vocal critics of this transfer decision. In a fiery interview, he questioned the logic behind United’s move, claiming that the club had made a grave error. "If I were a police officer, I would go to Manchester United. I would arrest the managers there. How can you just give McTominay away?" Di Canio’s comments reflect a broader sentiment among many who believe McTominay’s departure has left a void in United’s midfield, while Napoli has greatly benefited.
Under Antonio Conte’s guidance, Napoli has soared to the top of Serie A. The club's transfer policy, which saw the acquisition of players like McTominay, has been hailed as a masterstroke. Conte, known for his meticulous planning and ability to build winning teams, recognized McTominay’s strengths and brought him in to bolster Napoli’s midfield. The decision has paid off, with McTominay integrating seamlessly into the team and delivering impactful performances early in the season.
Di Canio's praise for Napoli didn’t stop with McTominay. In his interview with Il Mattino, he emphasized how well-rounded the team has become, highlighting other key players who have contributed to Napoli's dominance. “There are only reasons to be optimistic about Napoli,” Di Canio remarked. "Besides McTominay, they also have David Neres in reserve, a mature forward." Neres, who has been an exciting player since his Ajax days, provides depth in Napoli's attack, offering pace and creativity.
Di Canio also mentioned Billy Gilmour, the young Scottish midfielder, as another player who has strengthened Napoli's midfield options. Gilmour, known for his composure and vision on the ball, has added another layer of tactical flexibility for Conte. Di Canio’s admiration for Napoli’s squad depth is clear, as he believes the combination of these talents has turned Napoli into a force to be reckoned with in both domestic and European competitions.
Romelu Lukaku, the powerful Belgian striker, was another player Di Canio referenced in his assessment of Napoli’s squad. Lukaku, who has had a storied career in Serie A with Inter Milan, now finds himself part of Napoli’s ambitious project. His presence in the team, alongside McTominay, Neres, and Gilmour, has made Napoli a serious contender for major honors this season.
With the combination of these new arrivals and the tactical expertise of Conte, Di Canio is confident that Napoli will not only challenge for the Serie A title but also secure a place in the Champions League. "Napoli will definitely qualify for the Champions League," he stated, suggesting that the club's current trajectory is pointing towards sustained success.
As Napoli continues to excel, the decision by Manchester United to let McTominay go is likely to come under further scrutiny, particularly if he plays a key role in leading his new club to glory. For United, the question remains whether they can replace his presence in the midfield, while Napoli enjoys the fruits of a well-executed transfer strategy that has put them in pole position in Italy.